Skip to content
Forklifts or Electric Stackers: How to Choose the Right Tool for Your Operation
As for warehousing, it is important to be aware of all the nuances and possible consequences. The first step is to identify what you want and explore the possibilities for the further process. For moving products around your warehouse, you typically have two main choices: forklifts and straddle stackers. Both have their strengths and weaknesses, making it essential to determine which one best suits your requirements.
If you do not select the right equipment for your intended use, it will slow down your working rate, turning a 20-minute task into a 5-hour ordeal. This is why making the right decision and selecting the most suitable tool is crucial for improving the working process. In this article, we will discuss what forklifts are and how they differ from pallet stackers, the advantages they offer, and the challenges each appliance presents to help you make the right choice.
What is an Electric Stacker?
An electric stacker is a type of material handling equipment that operates entirely on an electric battery, requiring no physical strength. Unlike manual or semi-electric stackers that combine manual efforts with energy input, an electric stacker is designed to perform all lifting and moving operations autonomously.
Advantages of Stackers
- Maneuverability: Stackers are particularly advantageous in small warehouses or areas with limited space, as they can easily navigate through tight spaces.
- Cost-effectiveness: Manual stackers are generally cheaper than new forklifts and require little or no future modifications.
- Ease of use: Stackers are user-friendly and can be operated by almost anyone after basic training.
- Environmental impact: Electric stackers produce fewer emissions compared to other types of stackers, while manual stackers emit no pollution at all.
- Safety: Stackers come with features such as overload protection and anti-roll back mechanisms, which help reduce accidents.
What are Forklifts?
Forklifts are industrial trucks equipped with forks to pick and transport heavy loads using a steel prong or fork located at the front. Various types of forklifts exist, including reach forklifts, rough terrain forklifts, and counterbalance forklifts, each designed for specific tasks.
Benefits of Using Forklifts
- Heavy lifting power: Forklifts are ideal for industries that require moving bulky items, as they have a higher lifting capacity than stackers.
- Multi-purpose: Forklifts are versatile and can be equipped with specific attachments such as clamps, buckets, or platforms depending on the task.
- Quick and efficient: Forklifts can quickly transport large items across large warehouse areas, making them much faster for such tasks.
- Suitable for outdoor work: Rough terrain forklifts can operate on uneven or abrasive surfaces, making them suitable for construction sites or lumber yards.
Which Machine Should I Use?
Choosing between a forklift and an electric stacker requires careful consideration of several factors. Here are some key points to guide your decision:
Lifting Height and Capacity
If your average load ranges between 2000-4000 pounds (900-1800 kg), a stacker is most suitable, as it can lift loads up to about 15 feet (4.5 meters). However, if your operation involves moving heavier loads ranging from 3000 to 50,000 pounds (1,360 to 22,680 kg), a forklift is the better option. Forklifts can also reach greater heights, with some models lifting up to 30 feet (9 meters).
Workspace Constraints
Stackers are ideal for use in confined areas such as narrow aisles or small zones of activity, as they can navigate within tight spaces where larger machines cannot. However, forklifts generally have larger turning radii, making them less suitable for confined areas. While stackers are more standardized for certain types of work, forklifts offer greater versatility in performing various operations.
Cost Considerations
Budget is a significant factor when choosing equipment. Stackers are generally less expensive than other types of equipment, which is beneficial for those with limited capital or less demanding lifting needs. Forklifts, while more expensive, are still cheaper than scissor lifts and more maneuverable, making them suitable for organizations with higher lifting requirements.
Training and Certification
Stackers are typically easier for operators to learn, as they are smaller, less complex devices with fewer controls, requiring less rigorous training. On the other hand, operating a forklift requires training and certification to ensure safe operation and adherence to industry standards.
By evaluating these factors, you can identify the machine that is most suitable for your operation.
Choosing Between Forklifts and Stackers: Which to Select?
Whether to choose an electric stacker or a forklift depends on the specific needs of your operation. Electric stackers are easier to operate and effective in small spaces, making them ideal for limited-space environments. On the other hand, forklifts are designed for larger working environments and are best suited for moving larger loads commonly found in industries.
Ultimately, the choice depends on your operational characteristics and the types of loads you handle. We hope this comparison helps you make an informed decision.
If you are looking for an electric stacker, consider MechMaxx. We offer services as a material handling equipment supplier and producer in the United States. For more information, please feel free to contact our courteous customer care services.